Comments on: Hitler, my innocent hero

By: kilda

kilda — Mon, 30 Jan 2012 10:37:19 +0000

I DONT THINK THAT HITLER is a hero but most of the people voted like this i am in a dialamo on seeing the result is it he a hero.
but i like him for his courageous look and attitude
i THINK HE IS good intially but his environment and surrounding changed him

By: Bree

Bree — Mon, 16 Jan 2012 17:22:00 +0000

did hitler kill innocent people? no, no one is innocent. but it depends on what he was killing them for. if it was just plain prejudice, then yes, they were innocent. he never even met the thousands of people killed, so how could he know if he hated them? you cannot judge a book by its cover, just like you shouldn’t judge hitler. just like you shouldn’t judge anyone. i believe the reason people judge is because they see things in someone else that they don’t like about themselves. no, perhaps you didn’t kill thousands of people, but it just means that he carried out his desires. of course you have wanted to strangle someone, who hasn’t? but he just carried it out. am i defending hitler, yes, in a way. but am i against what he did, hell yes. i would defend anyone, even hitler. but i won’t defend them of something they truly are guilty of. if someone kills another person, does that then make them a terrible son, father, brother, uncle, nephew, cousin, friend, grandson, grandfather? no, it just means they commited a terrible crime. so is hitler a terrible person? no. i don’t believe there are terrible people. i do believe that there are people who make terrible choices, and he was one of them. we all make bad choices, but his physically affected many. it is your desicion to make as to whether or ont you want to judge him, but i won’t. i do not aprove of his desision to kill thousands of people, but he was a great leader who commited a great crime. and by great crime i mean a large ass crime. and by great leader i mean someone who others thought was worthy to follow. i don’t believe that anyone now knows his motives. i sure don’t, because i didn’t go ask him and say “hey, you know all those people you killed? why did you do that?” so he could have thought it was for a noble reason. i don’t believe he did a noble deed, but maybe he thought it was… we will never know.

By: Bree

Bree — Mon, 16 Jan 2012 17:04:07 +0000

the definition of a great leader is someone who people will follow. do i believe that hitler was a great leader? yes i do. do i believe that he did great things? yes, no matter how evil you are, you can still do great things. did he make a really stupid mistake? hell yes. no one has the right to kill anyone. only God has that right. i think that in his mind, hitler thought he was doing a favor to the world. alot of people have thought they were helping someone when really they just hindered that persons personal growth. there have been many genocides, so why is it just hitler that people get angry with? there was the genocide in ruanda, in china, and alot more. china killed more people than hitler did, yet most people don’t even know that china commited genocide. yes, hitler was a great leader or else he wouldn’t have had anyone who would be willing to commit this crime. the fact that he had followers meens he was a very convincing person. people obviously thought he was worth following. out of fear or love, we will never know, for we weren’t alove to ask him. perhaps it was out of both. but yes, i would say you could use the words great leader to describe hitler. was he innocent, no. did he know what he was doing? yes, so that means you aren’t innocent. did he personally kill jews, i don’t know and i honestly don’t care. he ordered them killed and that makes him guilty. was he a hero? to someone, sure. to me, no, he wasn’t. Some people vote for batman, others for joker. it depends on your outlook in life. if you think the best way to get revenge is to kill thousands of people, then yes, he was a hero to you. if you think he did more harm than good, then no, he isn’t a hero to you. he sure as hell isn’t a hero to me. there are good and bad aspects of every person. someone else posted and said it was the past, so look to the future? well, the past helps you learn, so use the knowledge of the past so that in the future, we don’t make the same mistakes our ancestors did. everyone has their own opinion, but the fact is that by the definition of a great leader, hitler was one. and by the definition of innocent, hitler was not. but the definition of a hero depends on your outlook in life and what you are trying to get saved from, so it depends on you to make the choice of whether or not he was your hero.

By: bhargavchowdary

bhargavchowdary — Sat, 05 Nov 2011 11:43:25 +0000

dudes some say Hitler is great some say Hitler is insane first of all think who was the cause of world war2 the four big figures of European nations those who wrote the humiliating treaty of Versailles .if same treaty was written for America,Britain etc..
they would have done the same.The leaders of battle won countries should keep in mind the The treaties like these will definitely leads to war.cumming to Hitler a correct leader for his country who rise his country from the ashes.So many thinks if Hitler was not there the world would be better.IF Hitler hasn’t not come there will be no heart surgeries etc….the Nazis done so many researches.IT is because of Hitler that change the fate of science in the world.the world will be 20 years back if wouldn’t come.U.S used so many of his researches after the war.killing Jews as he thinks they are the reasons of loss of world war 1 and agreeing for everything that allies said.so many says many reasons i think this is the main reason. HE is the great leader a country should definitely.these allied leaders Stalin killed so many .US also did many bad deeds that is why there are fear of wiki leaks.see they banned the net transitions accounts to Julian Assange
here what U.S did right means Hitler has done right thing. Here they are doing for their pride.my FUHRER did for this country .MY country needs a leader like him.whether so many likes him or not he is a great leader an a hero.helped us for forming INA(Indian national army)3rd largest army in the world.”Heil Hitler”

By: Peter

Peter — Wed, 19 Oct 2011 16:21:48 +0000

I think Hitler was the worst person in the world….. but if the Holocast never happened, then he would be treated as a German hero who lead the Nazi party in WW2 but failed to stop them from losing the war

By: Paul

Paul — Wed, 05 Oct 2011 12:57:32 +0000

I believe Hitler was a powerful leader that believed in what he was doing. He took a stand and didn’t waiver unlike many leaders today. I don’t agree with many of Hitlers tactics, but I wish our leaders today would stand for something instead of trying to make everyone happy.

By: Anonymous

Anonymous — Tue, 20 Sep 2011 02:41:31 +0000

Many people here have very different opinions about this topic. I agree that Hitler was a very bad person because he killed a lot of jews but what do we know really?? How do we know our teachers arent just teaching us the bad things because they dont want us to know the truth?? How do we even know that what they tell us about the Holocaust in their words hols truth? We should really research more extensively and then have an opinion but until now, i still think The Holocaust was unnecessary and that Hitler was an insane man for killing millions of jews.

By: Marble

Marble — Sat, 10 Sep 2011 15:45:14 +0000

Innocent hardly. But you know what? Who cares? Not to be mean but yes I realize he took lives of many. But in the end he did the right thing and took his own life. Not that that makes it any better but at least he did not live a full life either.

By: Tim R.

Tim R. — Sun, 04 Sep 2011 19:34:07 +0000

I have no problem with Hitler. He never did anything to me. Not that I was alive then, but he is dead now, so what is the point in hating him? He did wrong, but we all do wrong as some point in our lives.

By: Avi Bach

Avi Bach — Tue, 30 Aug 2011 19:48:49 +0000

LOL! Im a Jew and I dont give a shit about Hitler and his ideas. His thousand years Reich is no shit too! So except commenting here, go work your ass off, days and nights to reach what “Jews” quote and quote, strive for in their lives; speak wisely, think wisely and act quickly. Jews are people like you with goals whom they pursue non-stopping.